--

Well argued explainer article. Maybe you'd be interested in publishing it in Original Philosophy?

One the "Ship of Theseus" thought experiment, I think it is only a conundrum if we, as the Ancient Greeks did, hold a static view of identity. They saw unchangability as perfection, thus the idea that the Ship example provides that identity can coexist with change was baffling to them. I counter that identity is not connected to permanent traits, which explains away a number of philosophical systems. Personal identity is, as you point out, more complex. I gave some thought son this in an article awhile ago.

--

--

Douglas Giles, PhD
Douglas Giles, PhD

Written by Douglas Giles, PhD

Philosopher by trade & temperament, professor for 21 years, bringing philosophy out of its ivory tower and into everyday life. https://dgilesauthor.com/

No responses yet